Our Guarantee

We're a small, family business, which means your satisfaction is everything to us. We think of our customers like part of the family. If something went wrong with your order, please let us know. We promise to work with you to figure out what went wrong and to do everything we can to make it up to you!

How our website works

At the top of every page on our website, you'll see a bar indicating whether you're viewing products available for Shipping or for In-Store
Pickup. You can click on this bar to change which product line you're viewing.

If you navigate from one section of our site to another (for example, if you're on our "Shipping" page and switch over to "In Store Pickup," it may look like the contents in your cart have disappeared. Not to worry! You're actually switching between different websites, with completely different shopping carts. If you return to the section of the site you were shopping on, your cart should be exactly as you left it.

Absolutely! You'll just have to complete a separate transaction for the different sections of the site. For example, if you want to order both for "Home Delivery" and for "Distance Shipping," simply complete your "Home Delivery" purchase, switch over to "Distance Shipping" and complete your second purchase there. We know it can be a bit confusing at times, so please don't hesitate to reach out if you would like assistance.

You'll have the opportunity to add a custom note during the checkout process. If you have any trouble adding a custom note, please don't hesitate to email one to us at info@nettiesbakery.com. Each note will be printed with the packing slip and included with your order.

If you get confused or stuck in any way, please reach out to us. If you want Nettie's, we're going to make sure you get it!

General Business Information

Yes! So much more. Please stop into our store to see our full assortment of products. In our store, you'll find breads, pastries, rolls, cupcakes, cakes, pies, candles, jams, preserves, and so, so much more!

Our Bakery is located at 366 Railroad Avenue in Center Moriches, NY 11934.

We are normally open from 7AM to 4PM on Fridays, Saturdays, and Sundays. We adjust our schedule for holidays. Please sign up for our mailing list to receive updates about our schedule and more!

You can call the store at: (631) 400-9900. If the store is closed, please leave a message and we'll get back to you.

Alternatively, you can email us at: